RESTAINO CASE: Appeal benches judge

Local News

Discussion

December 17, 2007

City Court judge is removed with pay pending review of removal order

By Rick Pfeiffer/pfeifferr@gnnewspaper.com The Journal-Register Mon Dec 17, 2007, 10:14 PM EST

Niagara Falls City Court Judge Robert Restaino was suspended from the bench on Monday pending the outcome of a hearing before New York’s highest court on his future in the judiciary.

Restaino will be on paid suspension while the New York Court of Appeals reviews a decision by the state Commission on Judicial Conduct that ordered the judge permanently removed from the bench for what the commission called “an egregious and unprecedented abuse of judicial power.”

The removal order from the commission was based on a March 2005 incident that saw Restaino put 46 defendants behind bars after no one would take responsibility for a suspected ringing cell phone in his courtroom.

“We knew (the suspension) was being considered. We did not oppose it,” said Terrence Connors, the attorney representing Restaino in his appeal. The New York Court of Appeals ordered the suspension. It was dated Dec. 13, but wasn’t received until Monday. It follows by one month the removal order from the commission.

Connors said he hopes to be able to make his case to the Court of Appeals by March.

“(The review) goes on a relatively fast track,” Connors said. “I have 30 days to file and the commission gets 30 days to respond, so we could be in front of the court in 90 days.”

The court has the power to reduce the commission’s decision to one of censure, instead of removal from the $113,900-a-year post.

“Our focus will be to convince the court that the punishment is excessive,” Connors said. “This is obviously a difficult time for (Restaino), but he is focused on helping us prepare the materials on his exemplary life that we want the court to hear.”

The commission also heard passionate arguments about Restaino’s character and experience, but did not appeared swayed by them.

In a stinging eight-page decision, supported by nine of the commission’s 10 members, Restaino was called “a petty tyrant” whose behavior constituted “a gross deviation from the proper role of a judge.”

During a hearing before the commission, Restaino told the panel his conduct “was improper and inexcusable.” He told commissioners “he knew that he had no legal basis for (his actions).” He explained that he simply focused on attempting to locate the phone’s owner and was frustrated by his inability to do so.

The commission called his actions “an egregious and unprecedented abuse of judicial power ... in a bizarre, unsuccessful effort to discover the owner of a ringing cell phone.” Commissioner’s said Restaino’s conduct “caused irreparable damage to public confidence in the fair and proper administration of justice in his court.”

The judge told the commission he returned to court later in the day to release all the defendants who had been jailed. However, the commissioners challenged Restaino on that, saying that he began making arrangements to release the defendants only after court clerks begin fielding calls from reporters about what had happened.

Since 1978, the commission has recommended the removal of 156 judges, 38 of them full-time judges like Restaino, across the state. The Court of Appeals has reviewed 85 commission recommendations since its creation and upheld those decisions 71 times.

Of the remaining 14 cases, two were increased from censure to removal. Twelve recommendations were reduced, while nine recommended removals were modified to censures.

Restaino received support Monday from members of the Niagara Falls City Council, who agreed to submit information to the court of appeals reflecting the “quality of the judge’s character, his over 25 years of dedicated service and his otherwise exemplary record as a judge.”

Text Only

Local News

Test story
May 24, 2012
Market on Main will offer fresh produce, baked goods

Medina’s Main Street has more than its fair share of spots to pick up prepared food, but starting this summer there will be a place to buy artisanal bread and locally-grown produce.

Dave and Bonnie Reigle have operated a produce stand on their Ridge Road farm for 17 years. They plan to open Reigle’s Market on Main in the former Whole Nine Yards and be open year-round as a bakery and produce store.

April 18, 2012
Lyndonville BoE approves budget propositions

The Lyndonville Board of Education approved the four propositions district residents will vote on May 15, including the school’s $12,964,687 budget.

The 2012-13 budget decreases spending by 1.28 percent, but the property tax levy will rise by 1.95 percent to $4,620,374. The estimated property tax rate is $18.40, an increase of 1.38 percent and a bump of a quarter for every $1,000 of assessed property value.

April 18, 2012
Medina BoE OK's budgets for May 15 vote
Medina Central School District residents will have the option this May to vote for a budget that does not raise the property tax levy next year, but does increase the district’s budget by 1.74 percent.

April 18, 2012
Ridgeway sets public hearings
The Ridgeway Town Board will hold two public hearings at its next meeting on May 21.

April 18, 2012
Hoag will host STEM summer camp
The Hoag Library in Albion isn’t set to open until the weekend after Independence Day, but preparations are well underway for a two-week summer camp for a select group of Albion students.

April 16, 2012
Growing like a weed
The Orleans County Chamber of Commerce’s Home and Garden Show had a new home this year, and a record crowd came out to Knowlesville for helpful advice, information about local businesses and organizations, and a wide range of activities, promotions and giveaways.

April 16, 2012
Village budget talks continue

Medina’s 2012-13 budget is coming together at a series of meetings between department heads and village board members that largely focus on projected spending plans and areas where cuts can be made and additional revenue can be found.

The board met Monday with Police Chief Jose Avila, who said his department budget will be less than the current year despite increasing salaries and associated benefits.

April 16, 2012
Hoag Library era nears in Albion
The transition of Albion's long-time library to a modern South Main Street facility is quickly approaching, which had the Swan Library Board of Trustees discussing the closing of the current library in early June, a month of movement and plans to resume service at the new Hoag Library on the day after the facility's July 7 grand opening at their Wednesday meeting.

April 13, 2012
Pillars hosting Titanic evening

The extravagant experience that the high-class passengers enjoyed on the first and final voyage of the RMS Titanic will be replicated in a dinner at The Pillars Estate’s new ballroom this weekend.

The Pillars echoes the luxury liner’s grand staircase and chandelier, with historic touches throughout the restored County House Road mansion’s ballroom.

April 13, 2012
More Local News Headlines

Local News

Search Results

Discussion

RESTAINO CASE: Appeal benches judge

City Court judge is removed with pay pending review of removal order

Site Map

Contact Us