Niagara Falls City Court Judge Robert Restaino was suspended from the bench on Monday pending the outcome of a hearing before New York’s highest court on his future in the judiciary.
Restaino will be on paid suspension while the New York Court of Appeals reviews a decision by the state Commission on Judicial Conduct that ordered the judge permanently removed from the bench for what the commission called “an egregious and unprecedented abuse of judicial power.”
The removal order from the commission was based on a March 2005 incident that saw Restaino put 46 defendants behind bars after no one would take responsibility for a suspected ringing cell phone in his courtroom.
“We knew (the suspension) was being considered. We did not oppose it,” said Terrence Connors, the attorney representing Restaino in his appeal. The New York Court of Appeals ordered the suspension. It was dated Dec. 13, but wasn’t received until Monday. It follows by one month the removal order from the commission.
Connors said he hopes to be able to make his case to the Court of Appeals by March.
“(The review) goes on a relatively fast track,” Connors said. “I have 30 days to file and the commission gets 30 days to respond, so we could be in front of the court in 90 days.”
The court has the power to reduce the commission’s decision to one of censure, instead of removal from the $113,900-a-year post.
“Our focus will be to convince the court that the punishment is excessive,” Connors said. “This is obviously a difficult time for (Restaino), but he is focused on helping us prepare the materials on his exemplary life that we want the court to hear.”
The commission also heard passionate arguments about Restaino’s character and experience, but did not appeared swayed by them.
In a stinging eight-page decision, supported by nine of the commission’s 10 members, Restaino was called “a petty tyrant” whose behavior constituted “a gross deviation from the proper role of a judge.”
During a hearing before the commission, Restaino told the panel his conduct “was improper and inexcusable.” He told commissioners “he knew that he had no legal basis for (his actions).” He explained that he simply focused on attempting to locate the phone’s owner and was frustrated by his inability to do so.
The commission called his actions “an egregious and unprecedented abuse of judicial power ... in a bizarre, unsuccessful effort to discover the owner of a ringing cell phone.” Commissioner’s said Restaino’s conduct “caused irreparable damage to public confidence in the fair and proper administration of justice in his court.”
The judge told the commission he returned to court later in the day to release all the defendants who had been jailed. However, the commissioners challenged Restaino on that, saying that he began making arrangements to release the defendants only after court clerks begin fielding calls from reporters about what had happened.
Since 1978, the commission has recommended the removal of 156 judges, 38 of them full-time judges like Restaino, across the state. The Court of Appeals has reviewed 85 commission recommendations since its creation and upheld those decisions 71 times.
Of the remaining 14 cases, two were increased from censure to removal. Twelve recommendations were reduced, while nine recommended removals were modified to censures.
Restaino received support Monday from members of the Niagara Falls City Council, who agreed to submit information to the court of appeals reflecting the “quality of the judge’s character, his over 25 years of dedicated service and his otherwise exemplary record as a judge.”
Local News
RESTAINO CASE: Appeal benches judge
City Court judge is removed with pay pending review of removal order
- Local News
-
-
Snow won't last
The climate trend that’s emerged this winter — brief spells of cold and minimal snow cover, broken up quickly by warmth and rain — apparently will hold into spring.
-
Mild winter helps cut costs
The mild, warm, snowless streak of weather that snapped this past weekend allowed highway departments to tackle unseasonable projects early and avoid the high costs of snow plowing.
-
Sweetheart deals for local businesses
Local retailers will have a lot to celebrate this Valentine’s Day, but the joy will be mixed with exhaustion on what promises to be a busy day of deliveries and panicked last-minute purchases.
-
Lake levels cause concern
Land owners along Lake Ontario are concerned about a potential International Joint Commission plan which may allow water levels to reach higher highs and lower lows.
-
Tigers trio win sectional titles
Making a successful title defense, Lyndonville’s Sam Recco led a contingent of three Tigers to capture Section V Division II (small schools) crowns Saturday night at R.I.T earning trips to the upcoming state championships.
-
Hospice residence construction continues
The construction of the new Martin-Linsin Hospice Residence, which is now well under way just behind the Hospice of Orleans office building on Route 31 in Albion, will allow Hospice to provide care and assistance for those patients and their families.
-
Library construction, fundraising hit milestones
The project to build a new library in Albion is seeing a lot of green — both in the foam insulation that is being added at the South Main Street construction site and in Swan Library’s fundraising effort.
-
Albion plans for summer
Village officials heard details about this summer’s Albion Strawberry Festival and another big event that could bring visitors back to the village later in the summer — if concerns about street usage are cleared up — during Wednesday’s board meeting.
-
Theater impact grant formally announced
The National Park Foundation, the official charity of America’s national parks, has awarded the Erie Canalway National Heritage Corridor a 2012 Impact Grant to support the launch of the Theatre on Main Street project in Albion in collaboration with the Albion Main Street Alliance and the Western Erie Canal Alliance.
-
Inter-county collaboration
The Orleans County Legislature finalized a formal alliance with their Niagara County counterparts Wed-nesday, a move leaders from both counties said will lead to reduced costs and increased services.
- More Local News Headlines
-
Raw Video: Israeli Embassy Car Attacked
Coroner: Don't Know Houston's Cause of Death Yet
Valentine Greetings Sent Worldwide From Loveland
Greek Austerity Measures Spark Riots
Raw Video: Obama Budget Goes to Capitol Hill
Arab League Wants U.N. Help in Syria
Nordic Festival Puts North Korea in Spotlight
'Rumor Has It' Adele's Rolling in the Grammys
Grohl, Grammy Nominees Cut Up on the Red Carpet
Greece Passes New Austerity Deal Amid Rioting
Raw Video: Greek Rioting Ahead of Austerity Vote
Raw Video: Child Rescued After Kosovo Avalanche
Pop Music Superstar Whitney Houston Dies at 48
Whitney Houston's Church Mourns Her Passing
Reaction to Houston's Death at Clive Davis Party
79 Turtles Seized at Shanghai Airport
Fuel Removal Under Way on Capsized Italian Ship
Police: Houston Found Dead in Her Hotel Room
